Deflating Autonomy: Human Interactivity in the Emerging Social World

Cowley Stephen J.
Gahrn-Andersen Rasmus
Language of the article : English
DOI: 10.3406/intel.2015.1023
Product variations: 

Numerical(PDF)

Paper format

LOG IN
to download freely

This article critiques recent enactivist attempts to bridge an epistemological divide between the individual and the social (i.e. to fill in the posited macro-micro gap). Its central claim is that an inflated view of ‘autonomy’ leads to error. Scrutinising two contributions, we find that methodological solipsism taints Varela’s model: It induces De Jaegher & Di Paolo to ascribe social knowledge to perturbances – contingencies whose logic arises from the closed organization of an individual (De Jaegher & Di Paolo, 2007) and Steiner & Stewart to posit that the pre-dispositions of an organizationally closed world prompt individuals to “receive” shared norms (Steiner & Stewart, 2009). On our deflated view, neither organizational closure nor participatory sense making apply to most human cognition. Rather, we invoke a developmental process based on the recursive self-maintenance that is found in all organism-environment systems (including bacteria). Humans differ in that infants discover ways of making skilled use of phenomenal experience: they learn to predicate something of lived experience. As observers, they connect impersonal resources of culture (artifacts, institutions, languages etc.) with on-going social and environmental activity. This human kind of heteronomy links social processes to agent-environment systems that sustain – and are sustained by – historically positioned modes of life. Far from being organisationally closed, human subjects depend on using sensorimotoric prompts to connect the phenomenal with the impersonal and open up a partly shared, partly lived, reality.



Pour citer cet article :

Cowley Stephen J., Gahrn-Andersen Rasmus (2015/1). Deflating Autonomy: Human Interactivity in the Emerging Social World. In Stewart John (Eds), Cognition and Society : The social inscription of cognition, Intellectica, 63, (pp.49-64), DOI: 10.3406/intel.2015.1023.